Mella vs. the American Festival of Beige Foods
I've mentioned more than once that my relationship with Thanksgiving sits uncomfortably somewhere between Ambivalent and Belligerent. My reasons for this pretty much all have to do with the meal itself. Thanksgiving dinner is apparently one of those high points of the year that has people rapturous in anticipation. And I just don't like it that much. I'm generally indifferent to turkey, not at all fond of stuffing, and insulted by the combination of sweet potatoes and marshmallows, and the other elements of the meal just aren't things I'd ordinarily care to put together in one meal, if I thought to eat them at all. All in all, if I had to put together The Celebratory Dining Event of the Calendar Year...it wouldn't look much like what we're supposed to be fawning (and slaving) over on Thanksgiving Day. Also, the sheer abundance that's expected makes me uncomfortable.
The fact that everyone else is so excited about the whole thing does make it worse. It's like that band everyone was so crazy about in junior high that you just didn't get the big deal about. (I'm leaving the atrocious construction of that last sentence because it's necessary to the effect.) Even if you'd otherwise be happy ignoring the whole thing, the ambient enthusiasm starts to wear you down and make you cranky.
And there's the stuff I brought up at Wende's the other day - the fact that the holiday tends to make people throw sense and good taste to the wind in the name of some bizarre form of nostalgia. To be fair, I sometimes try to consider the possibility that that isn't what's happening at all, that people actually like dry boxed stuffing and corn syrup-infused canned cranberry jelly, and that I only assume it's an insane devotion to tradition because I don't like those things, but it's exhausting to think like that for very long.
I also find the whole thing to be emotionally manipulative ("Sure, I'm thankful, but it's none of your business."), but I'll admit that at that point I'm just being petulant. Still, attempts to make people share their thankfulness over dinner have never been tolerated in my home of origin.
Despite the above, I find myself hosing my immediate family for Thanksgiving this year. This is actually good for a few logistical reasons. My parents are rarely able to travel to us on holidays because of the Sunday morning factor - religious and weekend holidays are out, obviously. My mother's schedule is freer than usual this fall because her library is closed for a four-month asbestos abatement project (eek). I'm now centrally located between my parents and my sister the blond artist. And both of us have lately gotten to the point of giving up on Thanksgiving travel altogether - it's a difficult trip to make, just to do it again a month later for Christmas (and we'll both always be home then until personal obligations or future acquired familial connections dictate otherwise, or if my parents decide to spend their retirement as missionaries in Zimbabwe or something - Christmas is low-pressure and all around good with us).
Still, though, it's an event. Though my kitchen is fairly enormous, very little of that space is countertop. I just refuse to scrape together 17 different side dishes, even if I had that many pans to cook them. And I'm no longer up to being the annoying person who insists on swapping the turkey for Beef Wellington, just on principle.
Mom and I started talking through the menu on Saturday, and I think a tentative plan is emerging:
- Turkey: it's turkey. What's there to say? May do something with rosemary. (Aside: butcher called this afternoon and said, "I'm afraid I have some bad news." It was just that their supplier had messed up and they had to substitute my order for a different variety, but it's still not a phrase you expect to hear from the grocer.)
- Stuffing: I'm not fond of conventional bread stuffing, but my dad's into it, so I'm making mom bring the fixings. Ditto cranberry, even though that would be simple enough to pick up.
- Roasted root vegetables and maybe some squash: I need my vegetables as savory as possible, and if I use up all my bakeware on this, nobody will be able to make candied yams.
- Corn: Maybe? Easy, though.
- Creamed Spinach: Maybe? It's one of my favorite things in the whole wide world. After 30 years of indifferent platters of starch, I say I deserve it.
- Insalata Caprese: Maybe? It came up as a suggestion that made sense at the time, though it probably doesn't go with turkey. Mostly dependent upon November tomato conditions, though I'll need to think hard about sourcing decent mozzarella. Our standards were set by the stuff our Italian landlord used to make, but I rather doubt his process would meet with FDA approval.
- Rolls: from scratch, family recipe. They will not be shaped like turkeys, as has occasionally happened in the past.
- Pies: Mom will bring, since they're inconvenient to make same-day, and I won't really have the time to deal with it beforehand.







